Is U-Haul Or Penske Cheaper For Long Distance?

American National Movers
Jun 30
2 min read

U-Haul is a cheap option for short distance moving, but when you factor in the mileage surcharges U-Haul charges, Penske is a better, cheaper option for long distance moving. But pricing isn't everything—truck quality, reliability, and customer experience also play a role. On another note, there are affordable long distance movers, such as American National Movers, with full-service moving costs comparable to those of Penske and U-Haul. If you're looking for a more affordable moving option, consider American National Movers; you'll get a good value for your money.

With that being said, here's what you need to know about U-Haul vs. Penske for long-distance moving:

Hand holds wooden block labeled "QUALITY" with a checkmark. Adjacent block has "$ PRICE". Set on wooden surface, conveying a choice. — When factoring in up-front pricing and quality, Penske is not only cheaper than U-Haul they're better.

Why Penske May Be Cheaper Than U-Haul for Long Distance Moves.

Penske is more transparent about its long distance moving costs than U-Haul is. U-Haul's rates may seem cheaper than those of Penske, but their mileage fees make U-Haul a more expensive and riskier option.

U-Haul doesn't explain their mileage surcharge upfront, leading many customers to experience sticker shock at the drop-off state. This lack of transparency has sparked controversy, leading some consumers to accuse U-Haul of hidden fees and deceptive business practices (read more about U-Haul's hidden fees here).

In Simple Terms:

Penske charges customers a clear, flat-rate fee; U-Haul, on the other hand, has a confusing pricing structure that has caused consumers to pay more than they budgeted for.

U-Haul vs. Penske: Sample Cost Breakdown.

To give you a clear picture, here's a cost breakdown example for a typical 1,500-mile move in a 20-foot rental truck with Penske or U-Haul:

Analysis:

U-Haul's rates are initially low, but Penske often proves to be cheaper for long-distance moves because U-Haul's mileage surcharges add to the overall moving costs.

Penske Trucks Offer Better Value for Your Money.

Beyond a lower price, Penske provides a better overall rental experience. Here's why customers prefer Penske for long-distance moves:

Better-Condition Trucks: Penske's fleet is newer, cleaner, and more reliable, which reduces the risk of mechanical issues.
Superior Loading Ramps: Penske's has electrical ramps that make loading heavy items on their trucks easy.
Enhanced Comfort & Reliability: Penske trucks offer more comfortable vans, smoother rides, and improved safety features—important for long-distance moves.

When U-Haul Might Still Make Sense.

Although Penske offers better transparency and quality for long distance moving, U-Haul is a great option for moves within 400 miles or less. This is because shorter hauls with U-Haul will not exceed the "mileage allowance" and will end up being cheaper than Penske.

Bottom Line: Penske Often Provides a Better Deal for Long-Distance Moves.

If you're planning a long distance move, Penske has a more predictable pricing structure and better truck quality compared to U-Haul. While U-Haul can still be practical for local relocations, Penske typically offers the most cost-effective and reliable option for moving long distances.